Approximately 24 hours after I received my ASUS Transformer Pad TF300T 32GB tablet (as well as its companion keyboard dock), it’s already packed up and ready to be sold to someone on eBay (as Newegg wants $82.20 for restocking purposes). While the tablet itself is basically fine, the software that runs on it is not (at all). The problems that have plagued Android, ever since it was first released, are still present in Android 4.0.3, Ice Cream Sandwich. In a nutshell, it’s all about the apps and the overall user experience of the operating system. There was nothing about Android that I actually enjoyed.
Lack of tablet apps
I honestly thought that Android had more tablet-ready apps, but I was very wrong. What’s worse is that finding them is almost impossible, as the Google Play app doesn’t have a way to sort by smartphone apps, just tablet apps, or apps that are made for both types of devices. Facebook? Skype? Twitter? TV Guide? Enjoy using those apps on your tablet, as they’re basically stretched-out version of the smartphone apps (as that’s all they are).
Lack of quality apps
For the apps that I did find and what to keep installed, they were pretty mediocre in terms of layout, design, and functionality. You’d that that, for a platform that has been around for quite a long time, that the apps would actually be to a point where they’re presented in a way that makes its user think that they’re using something premium.
Performance
Even on the TF300T, a brand-new tablet with a quad-core Tegra 3 CPU/GPU, performance was rather poor in a number of different situations.
For example, Riptide GP (with maxed out graphics settings) played at about 25FPS, which was the case with Shadowgun THD, Shine Runner, GTA III, and a few more. Fruit Ninja THD, however, played at a perfectly smooth 60FPS, which it darn well better, since it’s an incredibly simple game in terms of graphics.
Another, more important, example would be when it comes to web browsing. The stock web browser often became unresponsive whilst web pages were loading. Speaking of “loading,” they were noticeably slow. And, again, for the hardware that this thing is packing, the web browsing speeds were annoyingly slow. I tried the latest beta of Google Chrome for Android, and it was even worse, with the app crashing multiple times or becoming unresponsive after a short period of time.
That’s it…
So, that’s about it. I had very high hopes when coming into Android, and it has failed me yet again. It’s been around long enough to where you’d think Google would understand the meaning of “user experience.” Without the apps that people want, and without them actually working well, your platform won’t receive good ratings, and it truly hasn’t (which has become apparent, thanks to Apple’s massive success with their line of iPads and high satisfaction ratings). Speaking of the iPad, I enjoy every minute of it. All of the apps that I have installed, I enjoy using. The apps themselves make me want to use them more and more, which wasn’t the case with Android whatsoever.
Next up: Windows 8. While I believe Microsoft has nailed the user interface and user experience, they just need to do something to get the massive amounts of developers to get on-board with it. Only then will Windows 8 be able to compete with Android and, perhaps, iOS.
Really you a very smart person. You really show that your a apple lover and not a person that can see thing objectivly.
besweeet
you’re*
It’s not my fault that this tablet fails in some of the most critical areas.
Mitch Samuels
And you know you’re a douche when your last resort is correcting grammar.
besweeet
I’d rather be a douche than an idiot.
Mklgjdklf
your both… such a joke of a user hands on. stop writing, your littering the internet with your crap
besweeet
I can’t tell if YOU’RE trolling or not. Regardless, it’s “you’re.”
Slaveze
It’s funny to see a review which at the end just compare the two stores from Apple and Google. Why do you bother testing such devices ?
You can’t expect Android devices to be as bug-free as Apple. It’s exactly like comparing Windows and apple OS. One is for people who accept having more troubles due to the diversity of available hardware but like not be chained to a single company and to be able to tune their product as they like (and as well spend less money) and the other one (Apple) is more for people who don’t know much about computers and want to have an all ready solution (and accept to spend way much money for the same hw)
So honestly your review is one of the worst I’ve seen so far. It’s like I would do a review of the IPad and conclude that it’s a piece of crap because I have to use ITunes…
BTW, you should rename your website Apple Erra…
besweeet
You obviously aren’t aware that this IS NOT a review of any kind. Your perception of the two operating systems is also correct. You obviously haven’t used both to judge them appropriately. Therefore, your comment is a huge fail.
Guest
dude..should have gotten the tf700….this(budget-friendly) model has an underclocked processor and other stuff….but you can get android 4.1 on it now which means smoother performance….however if you want a more refined experience…stick with the iPad…i mean 1 company making one tablet will make a better product than one which makes many…as they say..jack of all trades, master of none.
besweeet
Please, look at the release dates of the TF700 and the TF300. One can always wait longer and longer for something that’s better and better.
Jack
dude..should have gotten the tf700….the tf300(budget-friendly) model has an underclocked processor and other stuff….but you can get android 4.1 on it now which means smoother performance….however if you want a more refined experience…stick with the iPad…i mean 1 company making one tablet will make a better product than one which makes many…as they say..jack of all trades, master of none.
I agree I pre-ordered it and while I’m not a tech geek or know too much of it…considering the amount of power and the hardware they’ve packed into the device/ the performace doesn’t even come close to matching it. It’s so sad to see such a great device with wonderful capabilities go to waste :’(…I had to return my transformer pad at bestbuy (least I got my money back) now the newer model TF700 infinity seems to have more hope but hopefully Asus didn’t over promise us again.
besweeet
Well said.
Peter Knude.
Dude, i don’t think that you gave this tablet a chance, because you are the only one i’ve heard, talking about those problems, so maybe you got a broken device, or something.
Don’t blame the tablet, it’s good.
besweeet
I apologize for being far more critical and having much higher standards than others. This tablet sucks in so many ways that it’s unbelievable. I’m never supporting ASUS for anything ever in my life.
Peter Knude.
All your minor problems, was fixed with the Jelly Bean update, just saying.
besweeet
Heh… It required an OS update to be fixed. Huge fail in every regard.
Al
why is it that you do not allow comments on YouTube
Pingback: 3 weeks with the 2012 MacBook Air | MBA Users